Legal Memorandum/Expert Opinion: Case 1:04-cr-00320-AJT Document 1033-1 Filed 12/27/20 Page 366 of 4

EFTA00016784

Legal Memorandum or Expert Opinion: 2016-08-03-BA-Just-Doc-#110021

The document analyzes the Extradition Treaty between the US and France, concluding that there is no absolute rule against extraditing French nationals. It references a letter by US Senators Durbin and Obama and discusses the impact of a later EU-US Agreement on extradition, suggesting that France is likely to extradite Ms. Maxwell if certain conditions are met.

Exhibit A

Exhibit A EFTA00089447 WILLIAM JULIE AVOCAT A LA COUR December 18, 2020, Paris. Response to the government's memorandum in opposition to the defendant's renewed motion for release. I was asked to review the United States government's memorandum and notably pages 15 to 17 alongside the French Minister of Justice's letter dated 11 December 2020 produced as Exhibit B to this memorandum. 1 The French Minister of Justice's letter (Exhibit B) The letter of the French Minister of Justice, on which the US government relies to argue that the French government does not extradite its citizens outside the European Union and thus to the United States, quotes Article 696-2 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, which provides that France can extradite "any person not having French nationality". It remains unclear whether the author of such letter had actually access to my opinion which is not even quoted, and more generally it seems the letter responds to a question which unexp

Legal Memorandum or Analysis: 2016-08-28-2016-06

The document analyzes the Extradition Treaty between the USA and France and concludes that it does not preclude the extradition of French nationals. It also critiques the use of the Peterson case as a precedent for denying extradition, arguing that the decision was discretionary and not a judicial ruling.

Expert Opinion or Affidavit: 201-700320

The document, authored by French lawyer William Julié, discusses the extradition of a French national to the US, analyzing the Extradition Treaty between the US and France, and relevant agreements. Julié concludes that there is no absolute rule against extraditing French nationals and that the French government is likely to extradite Ms. Maxwell if certain conditions are met. The document highlights the importance of considering the discretionary power in extradition decisions and the impact of subsequent agreements on the Extradition Treaty.

EFTA01655304