EFTA Document EFTA01378479

7 October 2016 Corporate Credit,Energy Patrols° areallair° S.A. are compelling enough to compensate for the company's maturity wall (USD6Obn in four years and USD104bn in nine years), subordination risk and the significant challenge to contain its cash burn and sell a sizable amount of assets in a scenario of Brent price under USD55/bbl, all in absence of a material show of support from the government, which we fear that might not come anytime soon. In other words, albeit a timely show of government support and a meaningful improvement in the oil price or the Brazilian macro/fiscal dynamics, we believe the Petrobras curve should be steeper beyond the 2018 maturities (it is now flattish). In any case, Petrobras' longer- dated bonds may continue well supported in the near term on the back of the recently improved momentum for the Brazil-Petrobras complex and their lower bond prices (relative to the front end of the curve). We initiate the following pair trades: out of 7.575 '19s and into 5.75 '20s, out of '24s and into 3.0 ' les, and out of '24s and into '44s The 7.875 '19s to 5.75 '20s switch offers a price take-out of about 11.5 points and an yield pick-up of about 35 bps for a one-year maturity extension. The '24s to 3.0 '19s switch offers an important maturity reduction of about five years and an yield pick-up of about 55 bps, for virtually no change in price. The '24s to '44s switch offers a price take-out of about 5.0 points and a spread pick-up of about 10 bps. It is important to mention that only about 10% of Petrobras' debt is due beyond 2024 and by 2044, which mitigates the maturity extension from the '24s to the '44s, in our view. Figure I. Petrobran - Yield vs. Price and Pair Trade Ideas 11.00 10.50 10.00 9.50 8.50 * 5.75 20s 7.87519s 99s " 195 I. 4.875 20s 21s 4.875 1Bs. k zits. • ♦433 40s 41s. 23s. 245r --A 3.25 17s t 4 3317s 66 68 70 72 74 76 78 80 82 84 86 88 90 92 94 Source Onset* Oct Alciv r iseask* MOST nor Omer t; XIS Key risks In our view, the key negative risks to Petrobras include weaker-than-expected oil prices, production and USDBRL, as well as further deterioration in the Brazilian macro/fiscal dynamics, which could question the Brazilian government's ability to provide timely support to the company. High leverage (above 4.5x net debt to EBITDA), negative free cash flow due to heavy capex, a large maturity wall (USD6Obn in four years and USD104bn in nine years), and the possibility of significant subordination are important risk to bondholders. Petrobras has only one investment-grade rating (BBB- by Fitch) and two non- investment-grade ratings (Ba2 by Moody's and BB by S&P) and ratings upgrades are not likely in the near term, in our view. The key positive risks to Petrobras include a faster-than-expected rebound in oil prices, ability to increase domestic fuel prices in excess of FX devaluation and cost inflation, higher-than-expected proceeds from asset sales, and a timely show of support from the Brazilian government. Page 2 Deutsche Bank Securities Inc. CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0075659 CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00221843 EFTA01378479